What matters is what is said, not where it is said from

Many things must have been said and heard at the Bharat Summit in Hyderabad a few days ago, but two things continue and will continue to reverberate. One is Italian socialist Giacomo Filibeck repeating the Indian Opposition’s slogan, ‘Vote chor, gaddi chhod‘. The other is Rahul Gandhi applauding it. Filibeck’s utterance is seen – attributed to sources, not an official statement issued – as a serious violation of the conference visa rules, and Rahul Gandhi is being trolled for the clap from his seat. The platform Filibeck used is a technical matter.
Simply because an Indian activist or politician speaks abroad, or a foreign national comes to India to express an opinion, does not lend any additional value to what is being said. Or alter its import, whether it is pro-establishment or otherwise. The observations remain much the same. Only Indian responders who have narratives to carry forward and direct public opinion keep it going for longer than would be the case elsewhere – one incident, a studied response by the state or the injured side, and new areas are sought to forage in. In India, a horse has to be flogged.
Location of event of little relevance
In this age of instant response on social media to what is instantly uploaded, the question of where anything is said is of little or no consequence. Whether Filibeck spoke about what he thought of Indian democracy in Hyderabad or from some corner of Italy, he is an Italian and apparently travels around Europe and perhaps the world and would have had the same impact. The location of the event is of little relevance. The content of the speech and its import are a lot more pertinent.
How the incident in Hyderabad would unravel is anybody’s guess. It could slowly lose its significance as time goes by, or the army of protestors could keep it alive, much like the television news keeps it going, seeking views of the BJP spokespersons and their counterparts in the Congress and bringing in a couple of analysts to either add fuel to the fire or douse what has been lit, depending on whose side the TV is batting. Be assured, however, that it is going to be available on the shelf as and when the Right Wing needs a missile to fire at the Congress. The Congress, too, holds a stockpile for use against the other side.
Incident can be kept alive in public memory
Now a petition has been filed in the Supreme Court seeking the taking down of the videos on social media platforms, a probe into the grant of a visa to Filibeck, the role of the hosts, in this case, the Telangana government, and a public apology by them. Taking down the video would hardly ensure that what Filibeck has said would then quickly evaporate into thin air. The incident itself can be kept alive in public memory. The Congress would, however, as it has already done on some TV channels, bring up Narendra Modi’s remarks overseas.
Rahul Gandhi’s remarks at the Chatham House in London, in 2023 on Indian democracy, public policies in India, etc., and later his presentation at Harvard would be plucked out of the cupboards and flogged and Modi’s remarks overseas before he became the PM could also be the fodder for public comments by the chatterati and the social media. There is enough ammunition for both sides because, at any point in time, there is an election to be won or lost, and the Opposition campaign on the ECI and SIR and the BJP’s response to it would see arguments about it flying thick and fast.
In all probability, Filibeck would go on the blacklist of both the Ministry of External Affairs and the Ministry of Home Affairs. It can be taken for granted that Filibeck may find it impossible to travel to India in support of any cause, however dear it is to him. I cannot think of any other way he can be punished by the government of the day. Just like Helle Lyng Svendsen, the Oslo-based journalist now is – her visa was cancelled minutes before she was to leave for Hyderabad. But mark it, what she said from Oslo had as much impact in India as it would have had if it came from any platform within India.
Content holds more significance
That is the basis of my contention. The location is of less significance than the content itself, its meaning, or even the very purpose. Modi’s ‘Abki baar Modi sarkar‘ to a large rally of the Indian diaspora would have been construed to have the same meaning regardless of whether he went to the US and said it there in the company of Donald Trump. Or the boom, rumble and vibrations following Rahul Gandhi’s speech at Chatham House, or Prashant Bhushan’s assessment of the Modi government at the Oxford Union. Both Bhushan and Gandhi have been saying much the same within India.
We need to shed our thin skins and learn to take critical notice of India by anyone from anywhere – from foreign shores or on our native soil – in our stride and see what needs to change or be retained. The days of circumspection are over among the politicians, especially Indian ones, and what they speak is what they want to speak, no matter from where. Here is an analogy. During elections in India, where polling is held on different days, campaigns are disallowed 48 hours before polling. But a campaign, amplified by news TV and now social media, can be conducted in a neighbouring constituency or part of the state or the country where polling is on another date.
It is hardly of any purpose to halt a campaign in one area to allow it to be conducted elsewhere but with the same impact across all constituencies. Neither the Election Commission of India, political parties, nor electors are concerned about it. No one has raised any questions about how speeches across different dates can influence the voters who vote early or later according to the poll schedule. And in this new (mis)information age, the perch does not matter; the substance of what is said does. Let that sink in.
Get the latest updates in Hyderabad City News, Technology, Entertainment, Sports, Politics and Top Stories on WhatsApp & Telegram by subscribing to our channels. You can also download our app for Android and iOS.
This content is published by The Siasat Daily and has not been created or edited by Hello Headlines. View original




