Thursday, 19 November 2026LatestVideosAboutContact
Latest
Think CAPTCHA is verifying you're human? The ClickFix scam could install malware on your computerHyderabad semiconductor firm loses Rs 1.5 crore in email spoofingGrow Your Own Beetroot in Pots: Bengaluru Woman Who Grows 200+ Plants Shares Her MethodJaishankar meets Japanese leaders ahead of India-Japan 2+2 dialogueFloyd Mayweather’s felony charges dismissed in $200,000 watch case‘Someone always asks, why are you saving animals while humans are suffering?’Hyderabad student killed in US shooting, brother chargedRakshitha, 19, defeats former Oly champ Chen Yufei at Hong KongMumbai News: Bulldozer Action at Dawood Ibrahim's Ancestral Building in Bhendi Bazaar3 million IIFL Capital shares to change hands in Fairfax India dealIndia lose the plot after Jasprit Bumrah special on Day 1 of Wellington TestBihar Road Accident: Six Killed as Speeding Scorpio Falls into River from Bridge in Araria
NationalUpdated 22 min ago

Mansplaining, carefully: A man’s reply on International Men’s Day

Image: The Siasat Daily

I commissioned this piece. I read it, laughed in the right places, winced in a couple and then sat with it for longer than I meant to. My colleague Smriti Sinha ended by asking a man to explain. So here I am, trying to explain without mansplaining, which, I am discovering, is a bit like trying to whistle with a mouth full of biscuits.

First, a confession. She is right about more than she lets on.

Where she has me

Men did get a head start. In most Indian homes, the birth of a boy is still met with sweets and the birth of a girl with a polite “it’s all god’s wish.” Sons get the bigger piece of chicken, the later curfew, the benefit of every doubt. I have never once been asked how I will “manage” work after marriage. Nobody has ever told me to sit properly.

Smriti is also right about the campaign. Read that list of goals and it does sound like someone keeping score. “They have 13 days and we have none” is a sulk dressed up as an argument. And #GenderEqualityForMen made me wince too. Whoever came up with it has clearly never been in a meeting where the only woman in the room was never asked her opinion.

So no, I will not be defending the hashtag. If International Men’s Day is meant to be a race against Women’s Day, I would like to withdraw my entry.

The line she skipped past

There is one sentence in Smriti’s piece I keep going back to. Tucked in near the end, almost as an afterthought, she writes that for boys in middle-class families it is “a given that they have to earn.” She gets that, she says, and moves on.

I wish she hadn’t moved on so quickly, because that sentence is where most of this begins.

Most men I know can tell you when they were first asked their salary at a family wedding. The aunty asking does not want to know whether you like the job or whether you are sleeping at night. She wants the number, so she can place you, and your parents along with you, on a ladder the whole wedding can see. The girl standing next to you gets asked when she is getting married. 

Both questions are unfair. Both come from the same place.

That place has a name, and she used it herself: patriarchy. The same system that told her she could stay home told the boy next to her that he couldn’t. It told him a man provides, a man doesn’t complain and a man certainly doesn’t cry in front of his children. Most of us bought it. Some of us are still paying the EMIs.

The cost isn’t abstract either. According to the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB), nearly three of every four people who died by suicide in India in 2023 were men. In 2024, daily wage earners alone accounted for almost a third of all suicides recorded.

Put plainly, these are not men on a pedestal. Most of them never saw one.

About that consolation certificate

Her best line is the one about the race. The winner, Smriti says, now wants the consolation prize. I won’t argue with it. Men did win and asking for a consolation prize after that would be a bit much.

But I don’t think most men are asking for a prize. What I hear from the men I know is something closer to: can I stop running now?

The race came with rules nobody really chose. Earn more than your wife. Never look tired. Fix it yourself. The construction worker in Hyderabad and the boy alone in a college hostel, dreading a result that might let his father down, are running it as hard as anyone. Neither of them is anywhere near the podium.

Women have spent decades changing the rules of a race that was never fair to them. Some men would quite like the rules to change for them too. Not a medal. Just permission to slow down.

Why I think this is a feminist argument

I call myself a feminist, and I mean it. So, I want to be careful, because I know how pieces like this tend to go. They start with “I fully support women, but…” and end up somewhere unpleasant, usually the comments section of a video about alimony.

That is not where I am headed. I am not going anywhere near the reproductive rights line, except to say that a woman’s body is her decision. Period.

My point is simpler than that. Almost every problem on that list worth taking seriously gets better when men are allowed to be something other than the provider. A man who can tell his friend he isn’t okay is less likely to take it out on his wife. A father who takes proper paternity leave makes it harder for an employer to quietly pass over the woman who took maternity leave. A boy who isn’t told to “be a man” every time he cries grows up into a man who doesn’t feel the need to prove it.

None of that takes anything away from women. Women have spent a century asking men to change. Some of us would genuinely like to, and a day that helps us work out how isn’t a rival to March 8. It might be the reply to it.

What I’d want from the day

So here is my wish list, since everyone else seems to have one. Drop the scorecards and the hashtags. Talk about the labourer, the student, the father who doesn’t know how to hold his newborn because nobody ever held him that way. Get men to actually listen to each other, instead of waiting for a gap to talk.

And let women into the conversation, the way Smriti so generously agreed to be. Her piece made me think harder than most things I’ve read on a men’s rights website.

She asked if a man would be kind enough to explain this to her. I hope I have, though at the same time I’m not sure I have.

Get the latest updates in Hyderabad City News, Technology, Entertainment, Sports, Politics and Top Stories on WhatsApp & Telegram by subscribing to our channels. You can also download our app for Android and iOS.

This content is published by The Siasat Daily and has not been created or edited by Hello Headlines. View original

More in National

See all